Choosing Between an MSP and In-House IT for Small Businesses
- John W. Harmon, PhD
- Jul 3
- 4 min read
Updated: Jul 19
As a small business owner, every decision impacts your bottom line. One of the most critical choices is whether to hire a Managed Service Provider (MSP) or bring employees in-house. Each option carries costs, benefits, and potential drawbacks that can significantly influence your business's performance. Here’s a detailed comparison of the true costs associated with both options.
Understanding Managed Service Providers (MSPs)
Managed Service Providers (MSPs) offer outsourced management of IT services. These services include data storage, support, network management, and cybersecurity. MSPs have become a favored choice among small businesses. By opting for MSPs, businesses can reduce overhead while accessing expert services.
Benefits of Partnering with an MSP
One notable advantage of partnering with an MSP is flexibility. For example, a retail business can scale its IT support during the holiday season when consumer demand peaks. This allows businesses to adjust to high-stress periods without the long-term commitment of hiring full-time staff.
The Cost Breakdown of MSP Services
When assessing the cost of employing an MSP, consider the following factors:
Monthly Service Fees: MSPs typically operate on a subscription model, with fees ranging from $500 to $5,000 monthly. The cost depends on the extent of services provided, such as basic support or comprehensive cybersecurity solutions.
Initial Setup Costs: Depending on your IT complexity, setup costs may range from $1,000 to $10,000. This can include system integration or hardware procurement.
Variable Costs in Times of Need: Some MSPs charge extra during critical incidents. For instance, data recovery services may cost $200 to $300 an hour, adding up quickly during an emergency.
Long-Term Contracts: While signing long-term contracts can secure lower rates, they also lock you in, which may not be ideal if your needs change.
The Cost Breakdown of In-House Employees
Conversely, the cost structure for hiring in-house talent can be significant:
Salary and Benefits: IT employee salaries can range dramatically. Entry-level positions start around $45,000, while senior roles can exceed $100,000. Additionally, you must budget for benefits like health insurance and retirement plans.
Training and Development: To keep your team competitive, ongoing training is essential. According to the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), training costs can average between $1,000 and $1,500 per employee annually.
Overhead Costs: Beyond salaries, in-house employees incur costs for workspace, technology, and office supplies. This could add another 15 to 30 percent to your payroll expenses.
Recruitment and Turnover: Hiring can be costly. Recruitment and onboarding expenses may range from $4,000 to $15,000 per employee. In tech roles, high turnover can significantly increase these expenses.
Comparing Flexibility and Scalability
Flexibility is a core consideration. Businesses often face shifts in demand, and the ability to adapt is essential.
Advantages of MSPs
Scalability: With MSPs, scaling up or down can happen quickly. For example, if your company grows during a particular quarter, you can easily expand your IT resources without the stress of layoffs.
Drawbacks of In-House Hiring
Fixed Costs: In-house hiring offers stability. However, it can lead to fixed costs, even in downturns. This situation could strain finances during lean periods if you're locked into salaries and benefits.
Expertise and Skill Levels
The level of expertise is another critical point in the discussion about MSPs versus in-house teams.
High-Level Expertise with MSPs
MSPs generally provide specialized skills. Their teams often consist of seasoned professionals. For instance, an MSP may have certified experts in cybersecurity, which is essential, given that 43 percent of cyber attacks target small businesses.
Challenges with In-House Skills
In-house skill sets depend entirely on who you hire. If a key employee leaves, you risk losing valuable knowledge. Training new hires can take months, which delays operational efficiency.
Risk Management and Security
Businesses today face escalating cybersecurity threats that can cripple operations. Utilizing an MSP can enhance your risk management strategy. They offer continuous monitoring and regular security assessments.
Advantages of Using an MSP for Security
In-house staff can implement security measures, but they may lack the depth of expertise that specialized firms provide. According to IBM, the average cost of a data breach is $4.35 million. Investing in an MSP can serve as a preventative measure against significant financial loss.
Choosing the Right Path for Your Business
Deciding between an MSP and in-house employees involves numerous factors, including cost, flexibility, expertise, and risk management.
For small businesses, partnering with an MSP often proves beneficial. This choice enables you to access specialized talent without the burdens of hiring. Your unique business needs will dictate which option serves you best.
Conclusion
In a constantly evolving business environment, choosing a strategy that allows your small business to thrive and adapt is crucial. Take the time to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of MSPs and in-house staff. This process will help you make an informed choice that aligns with your long-term objectives and financial situation.
Let's discuss how we can save you money! Book your time here:
You can also recheck your security standing anytime with CyberScore:
Comments